Peer Review Process

Peer Review Process

All manuscripts submitted to JINCES are assigned to the Editor-in-Chief. The Editor-in-Chief considers the manuscript's compliance with our journal's scope and manages the double-blind peer-review process. Reviewers are an essential aspect of the scholarly publishing process. The peer-review process is used in JINCES to validate scholarly work, improve published work quality, and increase research community networking. JINCES applied a double-blind peer-review process.

Steps in the peer-review process

  1. Every paper received is first checked by the editorial team member designated by the Editor-in-Chiefto determine whether it is suitable for the conference's scope and quality. The chairs also look at the readability, structure, and grammar before considering it for the peer-review process.
  2. After the initial assessment, the Editor-in-Chiefchecks for plagiarism.
  3. Following the plagiarism check, the paper is sent to two or three reviewers for appraisal. Reviewers send back the paper after the appraisal for further processing by the editorial office.
  4. Once the review process is completed, the Editor-in-Chiefreleases the reports to the author/s. The author/s are requested to respond to reviewers' comments and suggestions and to effect the necessary corrections. After the authors respond to the reviewers, the paper is resent to the Editor-in-Chief for further appraisal and considerations.
  5. The editorial chair accepts, rejects, or returns the paper to the author effect any minor alternations.
  6. If the paper is accepted, the author will be requested to submit the final revision of the paper. Before publication, Camera-Ready versions are sent to the authors for confirmation. No further editing will be allowed after confirmation.

The Editor-in-Chief makes a decision based on the overall assessment and quality of the manuscript reviewers' recommendations. According to JINCES policy, the Editor-in-Chief’s decisions are made within two months from the day the manuscript was submitted. Authors remain with the manuscript's copyright, while JINCES will be permitted to distribute it across different online (scholarly) databases.